Craziest upset of the college football season happened on Friday night while everyone was asleep
Craig Carton unloads on the NCAA following their admission of massive protocol failures in the Michigan vs. Western Michigan Hail Mary controversy, questioning why the governing body even exists if it lacks the power to reverse the call.
Friday nights in the fall are normally reserved for high school football, but the college game had some pretty entertaining matchups that served as an appetizer for an absolutely loaded Saturday slate.
There was also Virginia Tech and Pitt’s thrilling (and controversial) ending in the battle of “why aren’t we ranked in the AP Poll” occupying the primetime slot.
THE CRAIG CARTON SHOW–UNFILTERED, UNAPOLOGETIC AND UNMISSABLE. DOWNLOAD HIS DAILY PODCAST NOW!
But, the most entertaining and consequential ending of the night happened in a small town in Idaho while the rest of the college football watching world was likely asleep.
The University of Idaho’s P1FCU Kibbie Dome, which opened in 1975, stands in Moscow, Idaho, with the Joe Vandal mascot statue in front. The dome was named after Potlatch No. 1 Federal Credit Union following a naming rights deal made with the university in 2023. The statue was created by sculptor Gareth Curtiss. (UCG/Universal Images Group via G)
Montana State waltzed into the Kibbie Dome in Moscow, Idaho, expecting to take care of business against a winless Vandals team.
Instead, the Bobcats bit off a bit more than they could chew.
Let’s start with the actual ending of the game on the field.
Idaho had the ball at midfield trailing 34-27 with eight seconds left and no timeouts – that’s an important detail.
As Vandals quarterback Joshua Wood completed a pass for a first down, the clock ticked closer to zero.
CLOCK CONTROVERSY: NCAA SAYS OFFICIALS BOTCHED REPLAY PROTOCOL IN MICHIGAN’S WIN OVER WESTERN MICHIGAN
That is, until Montana State coach Brent Vigen inexplicably called a timeout, essentially gifting the Vandals one last play.
An Idaho Vandals helmet is seen during second-half action between the Wofford Terriers and the Idaho Vandals on Sept. 19, 2015, at the Kibbie Dome in Moscow, Idaho. Idaho won 41-38. (Getty Images)
That strategy backfired horrifically, as Wood fired a pass to wide receiver Ryan Jezioro smack dab in the middle of the endzone.
An extra point would have tied the game and sent it to overtime, but Idaho said “no thank you,” and ran a QB draw to cap off a 14-point fourth quarter comeback with an outright win in regulation.
Pretty insane, right?
COLLEGE FOOTBALL WEEK 4 CONTENDERS, PRETENDERS: TEXAS SURVIVES, MICHIGAN’S KARMA AND COACHES ARE SWEATING
It gets even crazier when you consider that the Vandals were winless this season while the Bobcats were undefeated and the number one team in FCS.
Oh, and by the way, Montana State is the reigning FCS national champion and carried a 19-game winning streak into the Kibbie Dome on Friday night.
The Montana State Bobcats celebrate after winning the FCS Championship in overtime, 35-34, against the Illinois State Redbirds at FirstBank Stadium in Nashville, Tenn., on Jan. 5, 2026. (Getty Images)
Talk about David vs. Goliath!
There might have been some extra motivation in this one too, as the Bobcats knocked Idaho out of the FCS Playoffs in 2024.
High level, Power 4 college football is awesome, there’s no question about it, but if you can’t appreciate a good FCS matchup like this, then you don’t actually love college football.
Who knows what could happen to games like this if the highest level of the sport continues down the path it’s on, but for now, I’m going to keep enjoying some damn good football.
Thanks for an entertaining start to the weekend, Idaho.
